Skip to main content

Speaking out videos: MSF and North Korea 1995-1998

12 October 1996

On September 11, 1996, MSF received the Seoul Peace Prize. Philippe Biberson, Chairman of the Board of MSF France, highlighted the difficulty of assessing the situation on the ground in North Korea but noted that recent floods could worsen the population’s nutritional status. 

Source: AP 

15 May 1997

Regarding the humanitarian situation in North Korea, Tun Myat, head of WFP’s North Korea assessment team, said: 'The situation is desperate, and desperate people make desperate choices. Right now, they are eating whatever they can find.'

Source: AP 

31 May 1997

A Red Cross official reports that 60.6% of the children surveyed in North Korea suffer from malnutrition. Some European countries have delivered shipments of maize and cereals. But the United States and other nations have not provided aid, possibly hoping for the regime to collapse. 

Source: AP 

gettyimages.co.uk

8 July 1997 - Catherine Bertini, WFP (English)

Link to Video

11 April 1997

Returning from Pyongyang, U.S. lawmakers warn of the risk of famine in North Korea. They call for urgent food aid highlight that the lack of basic services risks pushing the army into desperate acts against South Korea.

Source: AP 

14 July 1997

In Washington, State Department spokesman Nicholas Burns said his government would commit to providing additional humanitarian aid to communist North Korea, which has been hit by devastating floods over the past two years. 

Source: AP

17 August 1997

Interview with Jon Valfells, Red Cross representative, who states: 'This is not like a famine in Africa, with large population movements searching for food. It is a silent and slow famine, but it is indeed a famine.' 

Source: AP 

October 1997

Documentary film by Mark Davis, distributed by Journeyman Pictures, produced by Hobo Media, 1997 (in English).

aparchive.com

7 December 

Following an exploratory mission in Kangwong Province, MSF met with journalists in Hong Kong. The organization treated 1,500 children suffering from severe malnutrition in its 38 nutrition centers. Dr. Eric Goemaere, General Director of MSF Belgium, emphasized that this number is limited compared to the province’s 2 million inhabitants and that there is no evidence to support claims of a widespread famine.

Source: AP 

Link to Video
aparchive.com

7 December 1997 

Dr. Eric Goemaere, General Director of MSF Belgium, has returned from a mission in Kangwong Province, North Korea, with footage showing hospitals lacking equipment and medication. The images notably show a young Korean girl undergoing an appendectomy under local anesthesia only. She died two days later from toxic shock after a dirty cloth was used as a tampon. 

Source: AP 

Link to Video

December 1997

Footage filmed by MSF inside a hospital in Kangwong Province, North Korea, showing the difficult conditions for staff and patients. 

Source: MSF 

12 April 1998

North Korea is calling for help: a large part of its population is affected by food shortages. Report from the outskirts of Dandong, the Chinese gateway to North Korea. Interview with Chinese truck drivers: 'The children are pitiful, they are starving and begging for scraps. They even pounce on an inedible raw material used to make soap, which contains butter.' 


Source: INA / France 2 (video in French, translated in English) 

Journalist: In Pekin, for the second day running, negotiations are underway between North and South Korea. The famine is high on the agenda; North Korea is calling for South Korea's aid as food shortages hit the entire population.

Report - Isabelle Bechler and Tristan Le Bras:
Dandong is one of China’s gateways into North Korea. It's a small place, with little activity, but it seems like a boom town compared to the rampant poverty on the opposite bank. Even the Mao of Dandong turns his back on Pyongyang. The only relief this little dictatorship has: one train a day and the bridge that brings in humanitarian food and goods to trade. These days the Chinese truckers take their lunches with them as there's no food to be found in North Korea. "The kids are in a pitiful state. You can see that they don't eat enough. They're always waiting for us on the other side of the bridge to ask for leftovers". "They're really hungry. We carry raw materials to make soap, for example - industrial stuff, totally inedible. But the kids can't cram it down fast enough because it's got butter in it."

Even if it pretends otherwise, North Korea can't hide what's going on at this border. Not one of the scarce factory chimneys is smoking, not even the faintest trace of activity, apart from the odd transhipment here and there. Just the naked, utterly desolate winter. Apparently ever growing numbers of desperate Koreans are seeking clandestine refuge in China's Korean families because their state has nothing left to give out. The daily ration per head doesn't even reach 300 grams of rice, the bare minimum for survival, way short of fuelling a child's growth. You do wonder how these kids on death row find the energy to sing the patriotic hymns they're constantly hammered with. And yet they get their best shot at nourishment in the crèches and schools. The only one spared: the army, which regularly kowtows to Kim Jong-il, the son of the defunct dictator. An army permanently primed to fight until it drops with the South - and with the West as a whole for that matter. An army frozen in the cold war.

14 June 1998

Press conference of representatives from the WFP and the United Nations Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO), returning from the affected regions in North Korea, presenting a worrying assessment of the crisis. According to them, famine is far from over. 

Source: AP 

30 September 1998

Interview with Dr. Eric Goemaere, General Director of MSF Belgium, who states that when MSF pulls out, people MSF assists in North Korea will be left with nothing and thousands of them will die. 'There is no alternative.'

Source: AP 

30 September 1998 

MSF leaves North Korea, considering that their aid was diverted to the detriment of the victims. Interview with François Jean, Head of Mission at MSF France. 

Source: INA / France 2 

Journalist: Médecins Sans Frontières announces its definitive withdrawal from North Korea. In this communist country, the horrors are indescribable. Hundreds of thousands of people have died of famine in three years. MSF denounces the authorities' diversion of aid.

Willian Eregoyen: "Some North Korean children are so weak they spend the whole day immobile, with haggard eyes. Famine - under-nourishment resulting from a severe deterioration in the situation over the last few years”, states Médecins sans Fronitères. Armed with testimonies from refugees who’ve crossed into China, the humanitarian organisation is sounding the alarm. Last month, an American delegation even evaluated between 300 and 800 000 deaths caused by the famine.

François, MSF project leader: The people most affected are certainly those living in small towns, industrial workers who aren't in the strategic industrial sectors or who don't raise any cash via exported goods.

Journalist: MSF will withdraw from North Korea. The doctors claim that their assistance was used to the detriment of the victims. UNICEF is not confirming the humanitarian workers' accusations for now. North Korea is still one of the most closed countries in the world. The United States, despite its massive participation in this aid, does not seem concerned by MSF's calls.

1 December 1999

Excerpt from the testimony of Ms. Li Song Hok, North Korean dissident, before the French National Assembly, where she recounts the abuses, she endured during 13 years of detention in a re-education camp. This excerpt is followed by an interview with François Jean, Research Director at MSF. He states that the famine in North Korea results from a deliberate decision by the authorities to let the population die. 

Source: INA / France 2 (in French, translated in English) 

Journalist: Good evening ladies and gentlemen. Let’s start off tonight with an exceptional testimony from an opponent of the North Korean regime. Her name is Li Son Hok and she was received at the National Assembly this Tuesday. She described to the deputies how she was victimised during her detention – thirteen years in prison for dissidence. Her aim; draw the international community’s attention to the political situation in North Korea, which remains highly obscure.

Peggy Leroy: Ms. Li managed to maintain her composure almost throughout her address to the National Assembly this morning. At ease among the deputies and journalists, this former dignitary of the North Korean regime began relating her story in a measured tone. She was arrested in 1986 for refusing corruption. Sent to a correction camp, she was subjected to Middle Ages-style torture for seven years. Ordeals that she still struggles to describe:

Li Son Hok: I was forced to drink more and more water. I fainted, I vomited, I had to drink more. Then I had to lie on my back while a plank was placed on my stomach. The police stamped on it, forcing the water out. It's impossible to describe the suffering this water torture causes. You think your intestines are going to burst and your stomach will rip open. The suffering is appalling.

Leroy: At present there are some 200 000 political prisoners, and above all, thousands of North Koreans are starving. These images date from 1998. They were taken by a North Korean dissident who returned to his country to film in secret. This documentary, which is rare, shows among others the many abandoned, haggard children with only fish bones to eat. The Kim Jong-il regime has the nuclear bomb, and a modern army, but deliberately leaves part of its population to die.

François Jean (research director, MSF): If there is a famine in North Korea, it’s a conscious political choice made by the authorities. The choice to leave part of its people to die rather than open the country up to external scrutiny and contact.

Leroy: Since the mid ‘80s, the famine has left between one and three million people dead. To prop up one of the world’s last communist dictators, this is the price to pay. Médecins sans Frontières left North Korea in September ‘98. The organization considers that its aid did not reach the victims, serving merely to strengthen the regime.

Jean: It’s clear that in North Korea there is a complete contradiction between humanitarian work, which aims to assist the most vulnerable, and the regime’s rationale, which is mainly focused on distributions to the army, senior ranking party members and economically useful people.

Leroy: Far removed from the gaze of human rights defenders, North Korea and its atrocities often go unnoticed. After the National Assembly, Ms Li is going to the European Parliament to remind democratic European countries that some walls are still left to bring down”.

26 July 2003

Marine Buissonnière (MSF) provides an update on the difficult situation in North Korea: soaring inflation since 2002 has almost wiped out the purchasing power of North Koreans, despite their efforts to survive.

Source: INA/ France 3/AP TV News (in French, translated in English) 

Journalist: It’s the fiftieth anniversary of the end of the Korean war. Ceremonies are being organised in Seoul and Pyongyang, the capital of North Korea, where the humanitarian situation lurches from bad to worse. No one knows how the 23 million North Koreans are really doing.

Report from Pierre Babet and Eric Jeannet: Fog. It masks the horizon, and the binoculars’ view. In the distance, we should see North Korea beyond the 38th parallel separating the two Koreas these last 50 years. What’s really happening in Pyongyang? Fog. What we do know for sure: there’s over a million soldiers over there that need feeding in the middle of a famine, and that means defections. How many defectors have left the ranks and are hiding in China? 100 000, 300 000? Choï Jing-i, a 40 year old literary figure, managed to reach Seoul with a few snippets of information; “The food crisis has got worse and worse. We always say that 1996, ’97 and ‘98 were the hardest years in North Korea. But it’s even harder now than it was then and there are so many people dying of hunger.” The previous famine decimated the country: two million deaths. Marine Buissonnière of Médecins sans Frontières is following the humanitarian situation in the North from Seoul: “The North Koreans have tried to set up substitution methods to survive. But since the reforms in July 2002 there’s been galloping inflation, prices have risen five, ten or twenty-fold, meaning that North Koreans' purchasing power currently stands at zero or there abouts. But they’re not paid anyway, or are only paid on paper if they’re fortunate enough to have a job, so they’re completely destitute, again”. Pyongyang has spent the last few days celebrating the armistice of ’53, which it calls “the Victory”. But 4.5 million North Koreans are totally dependent on external aid. This victory is a bitter one, and hearts are not in it.